Reply To: The horror the horror

Try Emil, Mark, Ross, Neil, George.

There are 5 very experienced new routers and rebolters all who do not advocate fear based removal of carrots. They all seem to accept that carrots are fit for purpose in some situations.

Given what those guys have done for WA climbing I would say their opinion matters WAY more than a bunch of random Rockface people who have never put the effort into anything.

And plus, all of those guys put there name next to their actions !