West cape howe death

Home Forums Climbing Talk West cape howe death

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2870 Reply
    Edd

      Hi all,

      Can anyone add/ correct/ clarify etc the news snippit that a swiss lady has died climbing at west cape howe this week? News.com.au states that she was climbing as does ABC radio. People have mentioned that she was just hiking though.

      I thought I would just ask as added to the tragedy that this lady has died (regardless of her pastime causing it) is the world of liability, and highlight to “the dangers of ‘extreme’ rockclimbing”, that this will eventually develop from it.

      My condolences to the ladys family and friends

      Edd

      #2871 Reply
      Jamie

        news i heard that she had fallen from the clifftop…30m to a ledge..i heard no mention of climbing or any other activity..

        i also add my condolences to her family and friends

        #2872 Reply
        Michael Webb

          Sad to say but I was a member of the S.E.S VRT team that attended the scene.

          May I first add I will not comment on cause of death or other details about the climbers involved. These facts are best left for the coroners report. I encourage CAWA to study the report when available.

          What I will say is that the incident occurred late Friday morning involving two non local climbers after completing a climb in the Pulsar Buttress area and were making there way to another route. A single fatality occurred after an apparent rock fall accident.

          There have been numerous rock fall near misses in this area and the degree of choss present near or on top of most routes is well known amongst local climbers.

          If you read https://www.climberswa.asn.au/Community/Messageboard/default.asp?view=message&id=384 you will see that between 1955 and 2004 there had only been 3 fatalities due to rock fall in the activity of rock climbing.

          This is not an official statement by FESA SES. I merely reply as a member of the team involved and as a fellow climber so that we may all take care.

          #2873 Reply
          Toc

            Thankyou for that Michael,

            I had rung Albany Police Station, but on Sunday there wasn’t much they could tell me other than it had been a tragic accident. The officer on duty told me the woman’s husband is being helped by the Swiss Consulate. I can’t imagine what he is going through and I am sure all of us echo the condolences already expressed.

            Toc.

            #2874 Reply
            Kath

              Hi all, Thanks for sharing what info you can with us Michael. From what you have said, it sounds like the accident occurred either getting into a new area or out of Pulsar area. Being the extremely safety concious person that I am, I’d like to share some thoughts on this and hopefully generate some useful discussion.

              Safety is so often only really considered while on a climb, the old 3 points of contact we all learn, and being taught to check each hold before you trust your full weight to it. How often do we really stop to consider the dangers getting into and out of a climbing area. I remember my first trip to WCH, being absolutely petrified trying to walk down into the Raft area. One slip and it’s a very long fall down toward the ocean. I seem to recall being warned to keep a bit of distance between us as we went down.

              Mt Frankland also has a dangerous walk in over slab to the terrace level, again when first starting climbing I was told to go up one by one. You would all go rolling down like a pack of dominos should someone near the top slip.

              Whether the danger is loose rock, other people slipping, or on the South Coast the ever present danger of King waves, all can be dangerous and it’s just so easy to become complacent about these dangers.

              Steve could tell you about his slip while trying to get out of an area in WCH. He ended up with a fractured hip only 5 weeks or so before he was due to go on a long mountaineering trip. Luckily his fracture was to a non-loadbearing part of the hip. Getting out of WCH was a long and very painful trip for him.

              The other thing to consider, especially when climbing the more remote cliffs, how much first aid knowledge do you have? Would you have a first aid kit handy? Could you tell if someone has internal bleeding or spinal fractures? The old safety in numbers is certainly true of the more remote climbing spots, as it takes a lot of people to lift out a seriously injured person. You also have to factor in the amount of time it takes to alert rescue teams. Few of these areas have mobile reception.

              Safe climbing to all, and my heartfelt sympathy to the climber who has lost his wife in such a tragic accident.

              #2875 Reply
              Ross

                How very true, Kath.

                Consider the case of Alex Lowe, who was a top notch ice climber and did all kinds of crazy stuff like climbing icebergs in Antractica, hard Hinmalayan walls etc. One day he was simply walking under an ice pinnacle near basecamp, the pinnacle (“serac”) spontaneously toppled over and killed him. Alex left behind a wife and 2 kids.

                Or Wolfgang Gulich who had a fatal car accident when returning from a radio interview (about his climbing).

                Statistics show that rock climbing is not an unusually dangerous sport, when compared with “common” sports like rugby and footy (other than alpine climbing which is). Deaths are highly unusual.

                I hope the authorities do not react by bans or restrictions, as climbing/walking/sightseeing are healthy activities and a great many people enjoy it. You would not ban footy if a player gets a heart attack on the field, would you…

                I can but hope that the lady departed doing what she loved doing. My condolences also.

                (I am married with 2 kids.)

                #2876 Reply
                Ben

                  I think it’s sadly ironic that most accidents happen when we aren’t climbing. We take so much effort and care to set up the actual climb that we are safe whilst there but we neglect the seemingly less dangerous activities like walking in/out or setting up the belay. It doesn’t take much more effort to anchor when putting yourself into a situation where the consequences of a mistake can be dire.

                  We climbed at Shark Rock on the weekend and whilst it is easy to walk up the back of it and onto the top to setup an anchor, I still had my wife setup an anchor further back to belay me while I made the actual toprope anchor. Even though it was a seemingly safe area, thinking it through, I decided that if I did slip/trip/overbalance or make a mistake, 7m is a long way to fall! Better to anchor in and be safe. Sure it may take longer to get to the fun climbing part but at least you’ll be alive…

                  Something I take from our safety guidelines at work. “Take 5”. Take the time to stand back and have a good think about what you’re doing and if you have covered yourself should an accident occur because “Accidents DO happen”.

                  Ben

                  (Climb smart – Climb safe)

                Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
                Reply To: West cape howe death
                Your information: